February 14, 2025 • 1hr 12min

TIP698: Best Quality Stock Idea Q1 2025 w/ Clay Finck & Kyle Grieve

We Study Billionaires - The Investor’s Podcast Network

In this episode, hosts Clay Finck and Kyle Grieve present their best quality stock idea for Q1 2025 - AppFolio (APPF). AppFolio provides software services to property managers in the United States, helping streamline tasks like tenant screening, rent payments, maintenance tracking and accounting. Since its IPO in 2015, the stock has compounded at over 35% annually and now has a market cap of ~$9 billion.

0:00

-0:00

Key Takeaways

AppFolio is a high-growth vertical market software company focused on property management software, growing revenue at 37% annually over the past decade
The company generates approximately 60-65% of revenue from payment processing fees charged to tenants and property managers
Market share has grown from 4% in 2015 to 16% in 2024 despite strong incumbent competitors like Yardi and RealPage
The business demonstrates strong unit economics with gross margins expanding from 55% to 65% since IPO while SG&A as % of revenue has declined from 54% to 24%
Management is heavily investing in AI capabilities through their Realm-X platform to drive efficiency and maintain competitive advantages
The company has strong insider ownership with founders owning ~11% and key investor Maurice Duka owning 18% ($1.7B stake)

Introduction

In this episode, hosts Clay Finck and Kyle Grieve present their best quality stock idea for Q1 2025 - AppFolio (APPF). AppFolio provides software services to property managers in the United States, helping streamline tasks like tenant screening, rent payments, maintenance tracking and accounting. Since its IPO in 2015, the stock has compounded at over 35% annually and now has a market cap of ~$9 billion.

Topics Discussed

Business Overview (1:49)

AppFolio was founded in 2006 by Klaus Schauser and Jon Walker with the vision of creating an ecosystem of software products serving different verticals. The company found early success with their property management software and decided to focus exclusively on that market.

Core product offerings are tiered based on units managed:
- Core: $1.49 per unit/month
- Plus: $3.20 per unit/month
- Max: $5.00 per unit/month
Target market has evolved from small property managers (5-10 units) to larger enterprises managing 1,000+ units
Value proposition centers on providing comprehensive, integrated software solution for property management
Currently serves 20,000 out of 300,000 property managers in the US market

The Five Key Stakeholders (13:04)

AppFolio's platform supports five primary parties in the real estate ecosystem:

Property Investors - Provide capital and own real estate assets
Property Owners - Legal owners responsible for properties
Property Managers - Handle day-to-day operations and tenant relations
Vendors - Provide maintenance and other services
Residents - Tenants who occupy and pay rent for units

AI Integration and Competitive Advantage (22:10)

AppFolio has developed Realm-X, their proprietary AI engine, to create competitive advantages and improve efficiency:

Automated workflows for common tasks like lease renewals and maintenance requests
Smart communication tools that draft customized emails and notifications
Intelligent screening of tenant applications with automated approval/denial processes
One customer reported "reducing pricing update tasks from one week to one hour" using AppFolio's AI tools

Payments Business Model (25:35)

A significant portion of AppFolio's revenue comes from payment processing:

~75% of revenue comes from value-added services, primarily payment processing
Charges $2.50 ACH fee to tenants for each monthly rent payment
2.99% fee on credit card payments (~5% of tenants use credit cards)
Payment processing estimated to generate 60-65% of total revenue

Competitive Environment (30:16)

The property management software market is highly competitive with several established players:

Yardi - Market leader founded in 1984, strong in enterprise segment
RealPage - Founded 1998, taken private in 2020, facing litigation over price fixing
Entrata - Well-funded competitor, raised $500M in 2021
AppFolio differentiates through:
- More seamless, vertically integrated solution
- Superior customer service and support
- Leading AI/automation capabilities

Financial Analysis and R&D Investment (39:19)

The company's GAAP financials require adjustment to understand true profitability:

R&D expenses represent 20% of operating expenses
GAAP accounting treatment of R&D "punishes" growth investment
Operating margins have improved from negative in 2022 to 18% currently
Management expects continued margin expansion as business scales

Management and Valuation (44:03)

Key considerations for management quality and stock valuation:

Management compensation appears reasonable:
- Base salaries ~$400-500k for executives
- Performance bonuses tied to revenue, unit growth, and margins
Strong insider ownership:
- Founders own 11% combined
- Maurice Duka owns 18% ($1.7B stake)
- Directors/executives own additional 10%
Valuation metrics:
- 50x free cash flow (unadjusted)
- 33x normalized earnings (adjusted for R&D)
- 18x sales, in line with historical average

Conclusion

AppFolio represents a high-quality vertical market software business with strong growth prospects and improving economics. While not cheap by traditional metrics, the company's market leadership position, AI investments, and strong management team suggest potential for continued value creation. Key risks include competitive pressure from well-funded rivals and high reliance on payment processing fees. The stock may appeal more to growth-oriented investors comfortable with current valuation levels, while value investors may prefer to wait for better entry points during periodic drawdowns.